Intermittent Fasting: A Dietitian’s Honest Take (Pros, Cons, and Who It’s For)

You’ve probably heard about intermittent fasting (IF) — maybe from a friend, a podcast, or that fitness influencer who swears it’s the magic solution for weight loss.

As a registered dietitian, I love looking past the hype to see what the science actually says. The truth? Intermittent fasting can work for some people — but it’s not the perfect fit for most. Let’s break it down.

What Intermittent Fasting Actually Does

Intermittent fasting (including time-restricted eating, the 5:2 method, or alternate-day fasting) basically means you go for longer periods without eating, then eat your daily food during a set window.

Research shows it can:

• Help some people naturally eat fewer calories

• Improve certain health markers like insulin sensitivity, blood pressure, cholesterol, and waist size

• Work just as well for weight loss as traditional portion control — when calories are the same

  
  

But some big studies have found it’s not automatically better than just eating fewer calories without fasting. In other words: how much you eat still matters.

Why Timing Matters

I often see people online suggest drinking coffee to suppress appetite in the morning, so your eating window can go from 12pm-8pm. While this may be the easiest window for your lifestyle, it may not be optimal for your body and goals.

Why drinking coffee on an empty stomach can be problematic:

• Spikes Cortisol (Your Stress Hormone) – Early in the morning, cortisol is already naturally high to help you wake up. Coffee can push it even higher, which may increase feelings of stress or anxiety.. and increase fat storage.

• Increases Stomach Acid – Coffee triggers stomach acid production. Without food to buffer it, this can irritate your stomach lining and lead to heartburn or discomfort.

• Can Cause Blood Sugar Swings – Coffee can prompt your body to release stored sugar, which may lead to a mid-morning crash if you haven’t eaten.

• May Worsen Hormonal Imbalances – Elevated cortisol over time can impact other hormones, like those involved in thyroid function, menstrual cycles, and metabolism.

• Can Disrupt Digestion Later – Too much acid early on can affect how comfortably you digest your first meal of the day.

• May Increase Anxiety or Jitters – With no food to slow absorption, caffeine hits your system faster, which can amplify nervous energy or shaky feelings.

Studies suggest that earlier eating windows (like 8 a.m.–4 p.m.) may be better, with benefits like:

• Better blood sugar control

• Lower blood pressure

• Improved mood

• Fewer late-night cravings

  
  

This might be because eating earlier lines up better with your body’s natural circadian rhythm — your internal clock that influences metabolism.

But, another important factor to consider is when your workouts take place.

Working out during your fasting window is not advisable.

Reasons include:

• Lower energy availability – Without fuel in your system, your body has less glycogen (stored carbohydrate) to power your workout, which can lead to fatigue, reduced performance, and slower progress.

• Increased muscle breakdown – Training in a fasted state can cause your body to break down muscle tissue for energy, especially during longer or more intense workouts.

• Higher cortisol response – Fasting already elevates cortisol (your stress hormone). Adding exercise on top can spike it even higher, potentially impacting metabolism, recovery, and hormonal balance.

• Reduced recovery potential – Without post-workout nutrition available immediately, your muscles miss a key window for repair and growth.

• Possible dizziness or lightheadedness – Low blood sugar during a fasted workout can cause feelings of weakness, shakiness, or even faintness.

• Increased stress on the body – While occasional fasted workouts might be fine for some, doing them regularly can put your body into a chronic stress state, making it harder to build strength and lose fat sustainably.

Men vs. Women: What We Know

For Women

• 10-12 hour eating windows are optimal for females

• Most short-term (1-3 week) studies show minimal negative hormone changes from shorter eating windows (like 6-8 hours), but there is no data to support long-term (4+ week) beneficial effects

• In women with PCOS, there’s some promising research showing benefits for hormones and metabolism

• Important: If your calorie intake gets too low, fasting can mess with your cycle, sleep, or mood. That’s your body’s way of saying, “This isn’t working for me.”

  
  

For Men

• 6-8 hour eating windows can be considered safe for men

• Similar weight loss and health benefits as women listed above

• Some studies show men may lose more muscle during aggressive fasting if they don’t eat enough protein or lift weights — though this can happen to anyone

The Pros (When It’s a Good Fit)

• Can make portion control easier without tracking every bite

• Often improves insulin sensitivity and cholesterol

• Earlier eating windows may help with mood, sleep, and blood sugar

• May help people with type 2 diabetes lower blood sugar (with medical guidance)

The Cons (What Most Blogs Skip)

• Not automatically better than normal calorie reduction

• Risk of muscle loss without enough protein or strength training

• May slow down metabolism overtime

• Inconsistency with timing of fasting window can reverse benefits

• Can trigger disordered eating patterns in people who are vulnerable

• Not recommended for pregnancy, breastfeeding, teens, underweight individuals, or those with certain health conditions without medical supervision

My RD Tips If You Want to Try It Safely

• Start small: Try a 12-hour fast

• Eat earlier: Aim to finish eating 2–3 hours before bed

• Protect muscle: Include 20–40g of protein per meal and lift weights 2–4x/week during your eating window

• Listen to your body: Watch for changes in energy, mood, cycle, and performance

• Women’s health note: If your period changes, or you’re trying to conceive, skip fasting and focus on regular, balanced meals instead

Bottom Line

Intermittent fasting can be a helpful tool, but it’s not a magic bullet. The best approach is the one you can stick with that also supports your overall health, hormones, and lifestyle.

Want a Gentler Way to Reset Your Body Without Fasting?

If you’re looking for a reset that helps you feel energized, less stressed, and more in control of your eating — without strict rules — join my FREE 4-Day Mind-Body Reset with Fuel the Fire.

You’ll get:

✅ Simple, satisfying meal ideas (no calorie counting)

✅ Tools to calm stress eating

✅ Strength-supportive habits to protect metabolism

➡️ Register now for the FREE 4-Day Mind-Body Reset and feel the shift in just a long weekend.