What Famous Athletes Wish They Knew When They Hung Up Their Jerseys
By Shanon Safi, RD, LDN, CSSD — Registered Dietitian, Sports Dietetics Specialist & Founder of Fuel the Fire

Fire Fam, I didn't know who I was after sports.
I played basketball and soccer my whole life, and later I competed in CrossFit. When the competing stopped, I suddenly had no idea how I was supposed to eat, how I was supposed to move my body, or what it all meant about me. How was I going to feel good about who I was without a scoreboard telling me?
Nobody talks about this. And listen, I was an athlete. A big ego can come with that. I think that's normal. You have to have a powerful belief in yourself to compete. But when so much of who you are gets wrapped up in how you look, how you perform, how you're ranked, and how other people see you, there's a lot of detangling to do when it ends.
So for Episode 75 of the Fuel the Fire Podcast, I gathered 75 lessons about life after sports from athletes who have done some of the most incredible things on the planet: Michael Phelps, Serena Williams, Abby Wambach, Kobe Bryant, Sue Bird, and many more. Because even the best athletes in the world go through this.
My hope is that two or three of these land in your bones.
Who This Is For
This is for you if you're a former athlete trying to figure out who you are outside of your sport. It's also for you if you're still competing and know a transition is coming, whether that's graduation, injury, aging out, or simply choosing to step away.
If your relationship with food, your body, or your sense of purpose got tangled up with the game, you're in the right place.
Lesson Set 1: Identity After Sports
Your sport is what you did, not who you are.
Kevin Love wrote about how your job doesn't define you. A title can never capture the infinite being you actually are.
Ask who you are without it, before the sport asks for you.
Abby Wambach talked about knowing her soccer identity would end someday. Start asking these questions before you leave. And if you've already left and you're still asking them, like I was, that's okay.
She also said you have to get honest about whether you even liked the old identity. Maybe you liked what you accomplished and what came with it. But did you like the emotional volatility? Did you like your worth hinging on how well you performed? Don't just shed the old identity. Build a new one that doesn't break when things outside of you change.
And give yourself time. Wambach retired at 35 and said it took her years to get her feet under her. That's normal.
You get to choose the word.
Serena Williams didn't love the word "retirement." She described it as evolving away from tennis toward the things that matter most to her.
This matters because your values need to live in your daily life. Without them, you won't feel fulfilled, even if you're at the top of your career, crushing it at work, or giving generously. External wins don't mean much unless you're living the values underneath them.
When the winning stops, your worth doesn't.
Missy Franklin built her whole identity on swimming, so losing races made her question what else she had to offer.
In sports, there's always a competition coming, a time to beat, a record to chase. Outside of sports, the wins look different. You might be an amazing parent, partner, friend, or professional. If you don't recognize those as wins, it's really hard to feel happy.
Franklin also reminds us that a huge part of your life is not all of your life.
You are a human being first.
Michael Phelps has spoken about seeing himself as only a swimmer, not a person, and how the darkness came when that identity ended. One of the greatest athletes of all time went through this. The people we look up to are living the same human experience we are.
It can be gone overnight.
AFL star Barry Hall talked about how sport becomes part of who you are from a young age, then disappears all at once. Sue Bird said the hardest part of retirement was mental, not physical. And Apolo Ohno described leaving as feeling like a divorce, even though he chose it.
You also won't be world-class at the next thing on day one. Being the best at your sport doesn't make you the best at everything else. When I stepped away, I realized I hadn't nurtured the other parts of my life the way I nurtured sports. It felt like starting over from square one.
Lesson Set 2: Mental Health and the Post-Sport Crash
The crash is the norm, not the exception.
Michael Phelps estimated that 80% or more of Olympians go through some kind of post-Olympic depression. He has talked openly about anxiety and depression after retiring in 2016, and in the documentary The Weight of Gold he spoke publicly about suicidal thoughts.
If that's hard to read, I see you. Having difficult thoughts is part of being human, and admitting them does not make you weak. I think it makes you brilliantly strong. Most people would rather suffer in silence, especially athletes. Nobody wants to be known for the fumble or the missed shot. I still think about shots I missed in high school and college.
Athletes are trained to hide weakness.
Lolo Jones has said athletes don't talk about their weaknesses. Of course we don't. We're taught to push and train through them.
Shaun White described an emotional crash after the Olympics that looked nothing like his public image. The higher the high, the harder the landing. Apolo Ohno said that for years after retiring, he tried to look perfect, until failure and pain taught him that life isn't. None of us are immune.
"Fine" isn't a feeling.
Figure skater Gracie Gold said "fine" was her favorite word while she was struggling. She described depression as feeling like her body was made of cement, not the obvious sadness she expected. And being seen as the golden girl made it even harder to be real.
Depression doesn't always look like crying. People can seem fine in front of everyone and feel crushed when they're alone.
Talk sooner.
Kevin Love has said he could have benefited from someone to talk to for years, but he never shared, not even with his family. Everyone is going through something you can't see.
Abby Wambach wrote openly about using alcohol and pills to cope, and about how stubborn and in denial she was. Numbing has a price.
Let yourself land.
Canadian basketball captain Miranda Ayim stayed at her parents' home after her final Olympics because she needed a soft place to land.
I had a hard time opening up to my family. Their response was often, "It's fine, you're good, why are you sad about this?" I think they just didn't know how to handle their own emotions. But when it builds up, you can't keep sweeping it under the rug.
Allison Schmitt talked about how hearing "you should be so happy" doesn't make you happy. People may see your success and not understand your pain. Don't deny what you feel. Find the people and places that meet you where you are.
Lauren Jackson shared a line that stuck with me: athletes die twice. Once when the career ends, and once for real, hopefully a long, long time from now.
Lesson Set 3: Food, Body Image, and the Changing Body
As a sports dietitian, this is the section that I'm most familiar with.
Eating was a job, and now it's not.
Michael Phelps has said eating was part of his job for years, so eating after retirement was actually hard. He had to relearn his hunger cues, and now he eats what he needs and wants instead of everything in sight. He also gained 30 to 35 pounds after retiring.
When you've been eating for performance your whole life, your body doesn't come with a manual for what happens next. A body change is not a failure.
The weight you fear may be the weight that's healthy.
Gymnast Shawn Johnson gained about 15 pounds after the Beijing Olympics and felt like it was the worst thing in the world. Later she recognized it was healthy and normal.
She also shared that gymnastics had decided her food, her friends, and her clothes for most of her childhood. When the sport chose everything, you have to learn how to choose for yourself.
Quick fixes don't fix it.
Johnson tried juice cleanses and detoxes after retiring. None of them worked.
This is a hill I will always stand on. The quick way never lasts. Real change comes from working on your relationship with food and your body, not from shrinking yourself and hoping you'll feel better. There's a huge mindset piece most programs ignore, and it's exactly what I specialize in: changing the subconscious programming that's running your life so it works in your favor.
Love the muscles that carried you.
Aly Raisman has talked about going from insecure about her muscles to learning to love them. So many female athletes feel like they don't fit the standard feminine look once they're no longer competing. Body peace is a work in progress, and that's okay.
"Thinner" is not a performance plan.
Runner Mary Cain has spoken out about being pushed to keep getting thinner. She lost her period and broke multiple bones.
This is RED-S, or Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport. When you don't eat enough for what your body is doing, your menstrual cycle can stop, your bones can weaken, your iron can drop, and your fertility can be affected. Being thinner and faster at the expense of your health and longevity is never the goal. And chasing someone else's approval keeps you stuck.
Your post-sport body won't match your competition body.
Your in-season body might not even match your off-season body. That's normal. The peace you find comes from your identity, your values, and how alive and true they are in your life.
Lesson Set 4: Purpose and Reinvention
Start building the next thing early.
Kobe Bryant started thinking about his next chapter early in his career. He believed the team-building skills from basketball transferred to business, and his message was simple: do what you love.
Less than two years after his last game, he won an Oscar for Dear Basketball. Your second act can surprise everyone, maybe even yourself.
Joy matters more than toughness.
Andrew Luck walked away from the NFL at 29 because the cycle of injury and rehab had taken the joy out of the game.
Choosing yourself might disappoint people. I heard it more than once: "Why would you walk away from something you're so good at?" Because my mental health, my physical health, and my longevity mattered more than my ego. I loved competing. I loved seeing what my body could do. But there was more to me, and deeper layers of my life to fulfill.
Your body gets a vote.
Lindsey Vonn said her body was screaming at her to stop. She showed us that unfinished goals can sit right next to pride, and that hiding pain to protect your image costs you.
Bring your mission with you.
Sue Bird planned to keep fighting so women athletes don't have to fight for scraps. I love that. Female athletes don't get the recognition they deserve, and they carry so much wisdom. Men and women both go through this transition, and we can all learn from each other.
Lesson Set 5: Rest, Joy, and Moving for Fun Again
No one hands you a schedule anymore.
After sports, you may lose your north star. You might not know what you're training for. That doesn't mean you stop. It means you find a new reason to move, and it can come from joy and pleasure instead of goals, scores, tracking, or beating your old times.
That takes a lot of rewiring. Be patient with yourself.
Movement gets to be yours again.
You're working out for health now, not training to win. You aren't running laps as punishment anymore. You get to reclaim movement.
You'll still have good days and bad days. You can miss it and still feel complete. You can love what it was and love where you are.
You still get to have a team.
Maybe it's not an athletic team, but you get to have a team filled with love and support. Your wellness has more pillars than physical fitness. Connect with people who get it, practice gratitude, and water what's good in your life now.
How to Start Rebuilding Your Identity After Sports
Try this today. Pick the one lesson above that hit hardest and write down your answer to it. Then ask yourself three questions:
What did I love about being an athlete that I want to keep?
What did sports teach me about food or my body that I need to unlearn?
What would it look like to move and eat from devotion instead of discipline?
You don't need all the answers yet. You just need to start asking.
Ready to Find Out Who You Are After Sports?
I created Body and Soul Freedom because I didn't know who I was after sports. It's my 12-week one-on-one coaching program for former athletes and ambitious women who want to feel at home in their bodies again. We blend clinical nutrition with nervous system and somatic work so you can rebuild your identity, make peace with food, and fall back in love with movement.
If you live in Pennsylvania or New Jersey, your sessions may be covered by your health insurance, and I'm happy to check your benefits for you. HSA is accepted everywhere else.
It all starts with a free consultation where we talk about where you are and where you want to go. No pressure, no strings attached.
Not ready for one-on-one yet? Start with my 4-Day Food Freedom Reset. For $27, you'll get concrete meal ideas, learn how to build a balanced plate, and start practicing intuitive eating so you can understand what your body actually needs now that you're not training like you used to.
If you're struggling right now, please reach out for support. Call or text 988 for the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, or call the National Alliance for Eating Disorders helpline at 1-866-662-1235.
Listen to the Full Episode
Want to hear me riff on all 75 lessons? Listen to Episode 75 of the Fuel the Fire Podcast wherever you get your podcasts, or watch it on YouTube.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is life after sports so hard?
For most athletes, sport shaped their schedule, food, friendships, body, and sense of worth from a young age. When it ends, all of that changes at once. Losing that structure and identity can feel like grief, even when you chose to stop.
Is it normal to feel depressed after quitting sports?
Yes, it's common. Michael Phelps estimated that 80% or more of Olympians experience post-Olympic depression. Feeling low, lost, or unmotivated after sports is real and deserves support. If you're in crisis, call or text 988.
Why did I gain weight after I stopped playing sports?
Your energy needs drop when training stops, but your hunger cues and eating habits often stay in "athlete mode." Your body may also simply be settling at a healthier, more sustainable weight. A body change after sports is not a failure.
How do I eat after I'm done competing?
Start by relearning your hunger and fullness cues instead of eating on a training schedule. Build balanced meals with protein, fiber-rich carbs, fruits or vegetables, and healthy fats. A sports dietitian can help you adjust without falling into restriction.
What is RED-S?
RED-S stands for Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport. It happens when you don't eat enough to support your training and body functions. It can cause lost periods, weaker bones, low iron, and other health problems.
How do I find my identity after sports?
Start by separating who you are from what you did. Get clear on your values, recognize the wins in other parts of your life, and find new reasons to move that come from joy. Coaching that addresses mindset and nervous system patterns can make the transition much easier.
—
Shanon Safi is a Registered Dietitian (RD, LDN), board-certified specialist in sports dietetics (CSSD), certified life coach, somatic and EFT practitioner, certified Buti yoga instructor, and founder of Fuel the Fire, where she helps former athletes and ambitious women find food, body, and soul freedom. Follow along on Instagram @fuelthe_fire or listen to the Fuel the Fire Podcast wherever you listen.
This post is for educational purposes only and is not medical advice.





Comments